On the one hand...

“I’ll say nothing without my lawyer. I know my rights!” Tony never spoke to police.

“Do you know how guilty that makes you seem, sir?” Tony said nothing.

By contrast, in the other car, Paolo said everything... well, not exactly everything. He explained how Tony’s twin brother was kidnapped and a compounding ransom had been demanded... about the fingers in the pies in the post, the cryptocurrency requirement, the need for proof of life and tonight’s race to the location coordinates provided. He said Tony had dealt with any ransom payment and he, Paolo, was Tony’s bodyguard.

All very believable.